The Courage Not to Know

Athena, the Owl, and the Wisdom of Leading Through Uncertainty

Throughout this series, we have explored the archetype of Athena as a lens through which to understand the development of a woman leader. Her symbols have invited us to examine our relationship with protection, power, and discernment.

Yet Athena carries another symbol, one that offers a different perspective on wisdom.

Associated with wisdom and the ability to navigate darkness, the owl offers a compelling metaphor for one of leadership's greatest challenges: moving forward when the path ahead is uncertain.

Every leader encounters moments when the answers are not readily available, yet decisions must still be made.

It is in these moments that leadership calls upon us to navigate uncertainty without requiring certainty first.

Ambiguity Is Part of Leadership

Navigating ambiguity is not a peripheral leadership skill. It is a core leadership competency because ambiguity is a common part of organizational life.

Change is inevitable in organizations. Priorities shift, strategies evolve, and leaders are often asked to make decisions without a clear answer or all the information they would like to have.

Leadership often requires us to move forward and guide others without knowing exactly what lies ahead. We are, in a sense, being asked to see in the dark.

And this is where I think we sometimes misunderstand what our teams need from us.

They do not necessarily need us to project certainty when certainty does not exist.

There is an important difference.

Certainty says, I know exactly how this is going to turn out.

Steadiness says, I may not know exactly how this will turn out, but I can stay present, gather information, make the best decision available to us, and adjust when necessary.

One performs knowing.

The other demonstrates leadership.

What Happens Inside the Leader When She Doesn't Know?

From my experience working with women in leadership, ambiguity can quickly spike anxiety. Leading without certainty can trigger feelings of inadequacy or fear of failure, making it more difficult to focus on next steps and what is known.

An internal tension can emerge when a leader believes she should have the answer but doesn't. She may begin worrying about making the wrong decision, failing to produce the desired outcome, or being perceived as incapable because she does not know what to do next.

Suddenly, the ambiguity itself is no longer the only challenge. The leader is also managing her emotional response to not knowing.

For some women, I don't know may carry even more psychological weight. Not knowing can awaken the fear that uncertainty will be interpreted as inadequacy—that somehow not having the answer means she is not qualified to occupy the position in the first place.

This is where self-awareness becomes essential.

Anxiety can draw our attention toward everything we cannot control or predict. It can create urgency where thoughtful consideration is needed or hesitation when movement is required. We may overanalyze, seek more information, delay a decision, or move too quickly simply to relieve the discomfort of uncertainty.

The leadership challenge is therefore occurring both outside and inside us. There is the organizational problem that needs to be navigated, and there is our response to the fact that we cannot yet see the answer.

The task is not to eliminate anxiety before moving forward. It is to recognize it without allowing it to take over the decision-making process.

The leader can pause long enough to distinguish between the situation itself and her discomfort with not knowing. From there, she can redirect her attention toward what she knows, what remains unknown, what she can influence, the resources available to her, and the next reasonable step.

This does not make uncertainty disappear.

It restores movement.

Learning to See Differently

This is where the owl becomes such a powerful metaphor.

The owl cannot illuminate the entire landscape before it takes flight. It does not turn night into day.

Instead, it has developed the capacity to navigate within the darkness.

The owl does not need to see everything in order to orient itself.

Neither does the leader.

Becoming more comfortable with ambiguity does not mean enjoying uncertainty, pretending we aren't concerned about what we cannot see, or recklessly moving forward without sufficient information.

It means remaining grounded enough to continue observing, thinking, discerning, and eventually acting.

The effective leader does not wait for the entire path to become visible. She identifies what is known, acknowledges what is not, considers what can reasonably be anticipated, and makes the best decision possible with the information available. As more becomes visible, she adjusts.

That is not indecision.

Nor is it recklessness.

It is the ability to make progress without requiring guarantees.

What Ambiguity Can Develop in Us

What if we stopped viewing ambiguity only as an uncomfortable condition we have to get through and began seeing it as an opportunity to develop leadership capacity?

When the answer is obvious and the path is clear, it can be relatively easy to appear confident and decisive. It is when the path becomes less certain that we become more self-aware about ourselves as leaders.

Ambiguity offers us an opportunity to discover something about ourselves as leaders. It is through navigating uncertainty that we gain a felt sense of our own capacity to remain steady, make thoughtful decisions, adapt, and move forward even when the outcome is unknown.

It can become a practice ground for leadership.

Each time we navigate uncertainty without becoming immobilized by it, we strengthen our ability to do it again. Confidence begins to come not from believing we will always know what to do, but from discovering that we can remain present, make thoughtful decisions, adjust, and continue to lead.

There is an important difference between confidence built on I know and confidence built on I trust myself to navigate what I don't yet know.

The second may ultimately be the more durable form of leadership confidence.

The Team Is Learning Too

The people we lead are experiencing uncertainty too.

And they are looking to us to understand how to navigate the current organizational climate.

They are paying attention not only to the decisions we make, but to how we behave while we are making them.

When a leader remains grounded, the team learns that uncertainty does not have to produce panic. When she remains flexible, they learn that changing direction in response to new information is not failure. When she invites others into problem-solving, ambiguity can create greater cohesion rather than fragmentation.

Ambiguity can become an opportunity for collaboration and innovation. When leaders invite different perspectives, challenge assumptions, and encourage exploration, they create space for possibilities that might otherwise remain undiscovered.

Rather than feeling responsible for having every answer, the leader creates an environment where the team can discover solutions together. In doing so, she strengthens not only the team's ability to navigate uncertainty but also its confidence in its collective capabilities.

Trusting Ourselves in the Dark

There will be moments when experience, preparation, and good judgment still do not provide a clear answer. Decisions may need to be reconsidered, and circumstances may require us to change direction. These experiences do not diminish our capacity to lead. They offer opportunities to discover and trust the resources we possess.

This is what draws me to Athena's owl.

The owl symbolizes wisdom that extends beyond what is immediately visible. Its ability to navigate darkness reminds us that our capacity is not limited by what we can see or know at any given moment.

As leaders, we can acknowledge uncertainty without questioning our competence. We can say, I don't know yet, without experiencing those words as failure.

The courage not to know lies in trusting ourselves enough to meet what unfolds, drawing upon the wisdom and capabilities we already possess.

← Back to the Blog · Clinical companion: Moving Through Life’s Uncertain Seasons →